
Please keep reading, I didn’t just put this here just to piss you off. I promise.
As an Atheist, I am a bit of an anomaly in the rooms of 12-step recovery. Normally in meetings, it is good etiquette to keep the references to one’s own spiritual choices to a minimum; we’re not there to evangelize, we’re there to share our experiences with addiction, our strength and hope in recovery. But of course, the subject does get touched on. It’s sort of unavoidable, since 12-step recovery revolves around the concept of a higher power and having your own personal spiritual renaissance. Usually, when the subject of a meeting involves the whole higher power thing, I end up referencing my Taoism rather than my Atheism.
Recently, I broke with that tradition, and met with a very positive reaction. So I thought I’d share a bit here too.
When I slouched into the 12-step program, I was pretty mentally beaten down. A long-time Agnostic, I did not really expect to find sobriety there, but thought I might pick up some useful tips on staying sober on my own. A lot of it made sense, though, and I saw a lot of happy, smiling people who looked nothing like the grim, teeth-gritting, self-denying, white-knuckling, unwillingly-sober-through-sheer-necessity people I expected to find. I heard someone share about their higher power being a popular stand-up comedian, and someone else share about their undefined, “there’s something, but I don’t think any human really knows what” Agnostic-style higher power.
So I thought, OK, maybe I can find a place here.
I was right, but not the way I thought. Over the last 3 years and change, I’ve given the whole schmear a lot of thought. And recently some more pieces have fallen into place.
Like I said, I came into the program as an agnostic. I prided myself on my intellectual open-mindedness, and I could not in all honesty present any evidence that there was in fact no deity of some sort out there. I still can’t. I also can’t prove there are no leprechauns living behind the garage, or that the tree in the backyard exists when nobody is looking at it. So what?
When I arrived as an Agnostic, I think my Agnosticism served a couple of odd functions for me. One, it preserved the possibility that there was something out there that could come and save me from my addiction to alcohol. If I could not be free of it here on Earth, perhaps I could be free of it in the next life, whether it was via some heaven or via reincarnation. Two, I needed the god-slot open for myself. I seriously expected the people around me to anticipate my needs and wants. To come save me from addiction with no effort on my part, to provide me with money and things, to give me a place to live, to compliment me and appreciate me no matter how crappy my behavior, to listen to me and do what I wanted them to. I wanted to be worshiped, I wanted the world to acknowledge my status as a special little snowflake and place me on an altar. I had to believe in the possibility of a deity, because I essentially assumed that I was one. Yeah, I agree. Pretty warped. Don’t get me wrong, I wasn’t sitting around thinking, “gee, I suspect there might be a god, and I’m it!” But that was the attitude I took into the world with me every day without really examining or understanding it.
Third, it enabled me to be an all-purpose people-pleaser. If you had a religion, I could tell you that while I didn’t share it, I sure did think your beliefs were possible and I would think about them. If you were Agnostic, I could tell you I agreed with you. If you were Atheist, I could tell you that I thought religions as framed by humanity were silly things, too. It covered all the bases.
So how did I make it from Agnostic to Atheist while participating in a 12-step program that has the word ‘god’ on damn near every page of the literature?
Because the program boils down to a couple of simple concepts. Be unflinchingly honest with yourself, about yourself. Figure out what it is that you really believe in; how do you think a decent human should act and think? Once you’ve figured that out, act on it. Every day, always doing the best that you can to act in accordance with your beliefs.
When I got honest with myself, I had to admit that I was not in fact an Agnostic, that I thought all human religions and deity-concepts were the product of superstition, and of making up answers to unanswerable questions. Self-honesty demanded that I acknowledge my own basic Atheism. So how did all of this fit in with the 12 steps, with their surrender to a higher power and asking that higher power to remove addiction and other negativity from the self?
Pretty easily. Am I powerless over my addiction to alcohol? I tried tons of different approaches to drinking alcohol. I tried drinking different kinds, rationing it, consuming it only at specific times or in specific places, drinking with other people, drinking alone; I tried studying the psychology of addiction and internalizing what I learned.
None of it worked. It seems that despite the best of my personal efforts, I stay sober best with some community, some support, some reminders of what addiction is like, some purpose attached to addiction outside myself, such as assisting others in their efforts to recover. If I did not identify with philosophical Taoism, the simple operation of cause and effect according to its own rules, I think I would call my higher power the fellowship of AA. Because being part of a support group has been a huge part of my success in remaining sober. I am grateful for the support of my family and friends, but it is that support coming from people who know what my addiction was like from the inside that provides the foundation.
But, I will occasionally be asked by a fellow 12-stepper, how does this work? How can you have the craving, the addiction lifted from you if there is no deity to do the lifting? How can you pray for help if there is nothing there to help?
For me, that has the smell of a fine (if overly lengthy and complex) Zen koan. How indeed? How can I describe the simple act of meditation with the intention of doing nothing other than seeing the unfettered world, free of illusions or my own assumptions, how it works, how its parts flow together, where they are moving, what my place in it at this moment is, and moving with it? How can I describe the act of seeking accord with the unknowable Tao, which has no sentience, no purpose, which does not even exist?
I can’t, but it works for me.
Psssssst! Pass it along. :)